A three-minute talk

Someone has to hold the spine

AI is the engine. Tokens are the wood. Who’s steering?

Tony Sciantarelli

The picture to keep in mind

The steamboat is the AI.

The wood is the tokens.

Somebody still has to steer.

1787 · The Potomac · Rumsey

The engine worked. Nobody was steering.

1807 · The Hudson · Fulton

Engine supply

Money

River rights

Fulton had a hand on the wheel.

1865 · Jevons, The Coal Question

Engines are dear: one boat, a little wood.

Engines get cheap: boats everywhere, a mountain of wood.

Cheaper engines burned more wood, not less.

Today

AI

tokens

~4¢

Now the wood is cheap. We’ll burn a lot more of it.

The steering

The buoys are the answer space: which answers count, set before the boat moves.

The pilot marks the channel first.

The harness

The governor: keeps the engine in bounds, every turn, without being asked.

The pilot: decides where it goes, and when to stop.

Build the steering into the boat.

Said out loud

It floats: the answer is well-formed.

Still under the surface: is it right?

Floating isn’t the same as safe.

What it means for us

More boats on the river means more pilots, not fewer.

Rumsey had the engine.

Fulton had the spine.

Sources

History. Rumsey, Shepherdstown, December 1787; Fitch, Delaware, 1787 and 1790; Fulton’s North River Steamboat, 1807; Gibbons v. Ogden, 1824; W. S. Jevons, The Coal Question, 1865; Watt’s separate condenser, 1769; Watt’s flyball governor, about 1788.

Decision models. respan.ai, promptql.io, hackernoon.com, amplitude.com/blog/jev-analysis, c-sharpcorner.com, zimaspace.com, pooyagolchian.com, thenewstack.io, theregister.com, trendingtopics.eu, aimlapi.com, techtimes.com. Speed: TypeSafe’s figures and an independent test. Price: published reseller listings.